Thursday, 16 February 2012

Tastes change and the big breweries follow

When Germans and German-Americans first started brewing in North America in the mid-19th century, they used recipes from their homeland. These would’ve been amber-coloured, flavoursome liquid-bread, matured for months in pitch-lined barrels in cool cellars. They were lagers, opaque, but thanks to the lagering time which allowed the yeast to drop they were brighter and lighter than the muddy, dark, prone-to-sour English-style ales which had been brewed since colonial days.

In Chicago, Philadelphia, New York and especially Milwaukee, lager breweries were started by German émigrés. To begin, their beers were mostly drunk by other Germans in their local areas. These German drinkers, foaming mug of lager in hand, also brought with them their drinking culture of leisurely mugs in beer halls with music, dancing, family and food. This was a stark contrast to the spit, sawdust and smoke of American taverns, where speed and greed were valued over pleasure. Americans were drinking spirits in the dark while the Germans were drinking lager in bright beer halls.

Men with the surnames Anheuser, Busch, Best (to be passed on to Pabst) and Uehlein (Schlitz) had started their breweries. And they grew quickly, re-writing what brewing was in America and creating their own fortunes with ingenuity, determination and ambition. These were the guys who first used refrigeration for beer, who first pasteurised their beer, who built enormous automated bottling lines (in the 1890s, Pabst’s bottling line employed over 900 people and could fill 75,000 bottles an hour per spindle of their line; they had 96 spindles), developed transport networks around America in order to sell more beer and grew local, then national, then international companies.  

As the numbers of German-Americans grew, so their beer spread further and Americans started drinking it. But the American taste for beer was different to that of Europeans: they didn’t want the ‘heavy’ Bavarian beers, they wanted something lighter – it was the German historical nourishment of liquid bread versus the American need for drunken speed. So beers evolved or new brands were released to satisfy the market demand.

In the 1870s, brewers looked back to Europe and saw the bright beers of Bohemia – pale gold, light-bodied, clear and sparkling. This was the style of beer which Americans would like, the sort of beer they could drink lots of. But it proved difficult to brew. Europeans used two-row barley but Americans used six-row barley; six-row is rich in protein and some of that remained in the finished beer, forming a haze or unsightly clumps, as well as reducing shelf-life (this is still pre-pasteurisation). Darker Bavarian lagers could hide this haze but pale Pilsners couldn’t. And this new beer style arrived at the same time as glass became the drinking container of choice: suddenly beer had to look good.

This is where adjuncts come in. Brewers needed something with starch and useful sugars to reduce the amount of barley. Corn worked; it absorbed excess protein in the barley and stretched the six-row further (meaning less needed to be used for beer-quality reasons rather than financial ones), but it also added an unpleasant flavour as it contained oil. A better adjunct was rice. This new light, clear lager was now a beer unique to America, used in order to produce a better, brighter beer, not a cheaper one. And this modern beer was exactly to American tastes where quality quickly became associated with pale and sparkling.

Throughout this period, the successful breweries – Anheuser-Busch, Pabst, Schlitz – were focused on quality, consistency and reaching new drinkers, and they brewed, by all accounts, some of the best beers in the world, reaching a notable high in the battle at the World Expo of 1893 which awarded Pabst the medal for which it still wears a blue ribbon today – Budweiser took second place, beating lagers and ales from around the world, including the German beers which inspired the new style of American lager. 

Then came Prohibition. More than a decade dry, America had turned to soda and 13-year habits are hard to kick. Those dry years saw big advancements in life: people now spent time at home where they could listen to the radio or spend time with their family, and if they drank then they did so at home (packaged beer was 10% of the market in 1919; by 1940 it was split 50-50; by 1960 it was 80% packaged), or they’d go to the movies, where they’d watch svelte Hollywood starlets sipping cocktails (post-Prohibition, obviously), a sight far removed from the bouncy Bavarian beer wenches.

Then came recession, the Great Depression, World War II and ingredient rationing. Some brewers changed and cheapened recipes to keep away from bank managers or to keep up with demand; others, including some of the big guys, for whom premium quality was essential, refused to compromise on ingredients and so brewed less. When recession and rationed ended, some breweries just carried on using the adjuncts, liking the savings they made on cheaper ingredients.

Times changed again. The knock-on from Prohibition to war to general technological, commercial and industrial advancement saw a very different America in the 1950s to how it’d been 40 years earlier. The ‘drinking demographic’ of 20-40 year olds was low in the 1950s and spirit sales went up while beer sales went down. Dieting and bad health became part of the public conscience and beer was unable to rid the wench’s fat-fingered grip. The rationed diet of the last two decades also saw a blanket blandness and a palate that wanted sweetness combined with a new desire for convenience, so mass-market beers sat beside sliced white bread and packets of processed cheese.

As had happened in the 1870s, when the amber beers of Bavaria became the pale beers of Bohemia, so in the 1950s Americans wanted less-demanding drinks and beer changed to suit to the tastes of the nation.

Enter lighter beers, drier beers, weaker beers and, in the 1970s, Lite beers. These brewhouse changes happened with a backdrop of mergers, takeovers, buyouts and breweries going bust, as the big boys looked to spread across America while the small breweries just tried to keep going. Survival was made harder as consumers started looking for cheaper beers over premium ones – the big brewers adapted and had the mountainous volumes to push prices lower and lower, forcing the small breweries to fight over dimes, not dollars. Brewing corporations brutally ruled the market.

Then things changed again. The liberal, world-conscious and curious attitude of the 1960s and 70s saw people travelling more and experiencing other cultures, which saw import beers rise in popularity. Then came homebrewing (though still illegal until 1979), an extension of a growing knowledge of food and ingredients, and a way away from the corporations and towards small producers. Changes were happening while the big brewers were still perpetually searching for new markets, still spending millions on advertising and still changing their recipes by reducing rather than adding flavour.

The change started with Anchor, New Albion, Sierra Nevada, Redhook, Boulder Brewing, Mendocino Brewing and others. Then come more and more. Followed by an on-going burst in America since the 1990s. In 1880s, there were over 4,000 breweries in America, which dropped to around 1,500 before Prohibition, of which less than 200 survived to the repeal of the amendment. In the mid-1980s there was only around 80 breweries owned by 60-odd brewing companies. There are now around 2,000 craft breweries in America with over 900 in planning (in the UK, in 1910 there was over 4,500 breweries, dropping to just 191 in 1980; now there are over 1,000). The small guy now had a say.

‘We are the 5%’ has become a proud bumper-sticker-slogan for the craft beer minority of America. Brewing is booming, even if the big companies, which are now really big companies thanks to mergers and takeovers, still hold the huge majority of market share; the monolithic giants are being pushed around by a growing army of little guys.

In the 1870s and again in the 1950s, German-American breweries changed their recipes to suit what the drinkers wanted. Now look at the last 15 years. The main brands rarely change but big brewers are always searching to be at the forefront of things, to position themselves to slot into different markets with different products: Blue Moon, Budweiser American Ale or the Brewmaster’s Private Reserve, Shock Top, Green Valley Brewing or see the list of AB-InBev brands, especially the Michelob brews which includes a lager funked up with brettanomyces and a Rye Pale Ale. The big brewers are now having to seek inspiration from the craft breweries, from the guys who are closer to the drinkers, more able to see how tastes are developing and shape where things go.

But this isn’t about the big brewers any more. While it’s interesting to see what they do, they are being reactive instead of proactive. The forefront of the industry is now taking place in small mash tuns around the world by brewers who are creative and passionate and dedicated to making great-tasting beers with personality and character and flavour.

The current trend is towards big flavour in beer. It’s the antithesis of the light/lite lagers which dominate bar tops and home fridges. These beers show you how different beer can be, how varied, how exciting. Not long ago, the beers of Belgium would’ve converted new drinkers but now it’s more likely they’ll have a double IPA than an abbey dubbel, and we have American brewers to thank for that, but we can also look at New Zealand, Sweden, Italy and the UK as countries who are taking beer further, doing new things, giving drinkers more and better choices.

And choice is what’s great about beer right now. It’s hard to introspect what’s happening in terms of changing tastes but we can anecdotally see that more hops are being added to beers, different hop varieties are being used, strong beers are no longer fearsome, breweries are experimenting with different styles, ingredients and yeasts, sour beers are a big thing in America, barrel-aging isn’t slowing down, old recipes are being recreated and new ones are changing what we thought we knew about beer.

Before travel networks were laid across America all beer was local. This allowed for those 4,000 breweries to operate in the 1880s as each had their own market. With roads, trains, ships and planes, plus pasteurisation, bottling, canning and refrigeration, breweries were able to ship beer further and look nationally instead of just nearby. Now provenance is back. There’s an interest in where things are from and there’s a parochial pride in supporting local businesses and community. And that’s making room for more new breweries to start filling their fermenters all over the world.   

Tastes change. The big brewers have always had to react to the tastes of their drinkers: opaque, heavy amber lager became pale and sparkling pilsners which then became lighter, drier lagers. Now flavour is back and drinkers are more knowledgeable and curious than ever. The full-on aroma of American hops is an exciting change to the tastebuds, a rich stout is deeply satisfying, a sharp sour is refreshing and complex and lagers have their flavour back. 

Tastes change and who knows what’s next. Who knows how the big brewers will react to it – maybe it’ll be buying more craft breweries, maybe building new breweries of their own and backing it up with advertising spend, maybe we’ll see them recreate their pre-Prohibition lagers. Who cares how they’ll react; there are a handful of them and thousands of us now. As knowledge grows, as people experience different beers, as the thousands become tens-of-thousands and the mash tuns go from 5 barrels to 50, so tastes will change and drinkers will want different things. The past is fascinating; the present is exciting; the future is going to taste even better.  


A lot of the history stuff comes from reading Maureen Ogle’s excellent Ambitious Brew. If you haven’t read it then you must. The whole story of American beer is deeply fascinating and was the inspiration for writing this.

Ken Wells’s Travels With Barley also helped form my knowledge of American beer.

Randy Mosher filled in some gaps on the history of American beer in Tasting Beer.

The Oxford Companion to Beer is always a great resource to dip into.

Stats and figures come from The 2011-2012 Cask Report, the British Beer and Pub Association’s Statistical Handbook 2011 and via pages linked above.

Images from here, here, here, here, here and here.


  1. Nice work, Mark, just the right length! Of course, you're right. Despite owning such market share, larger companies (be it beer, or fashion, or films) always keep a wary eye on the zeitgiest, and then (probably) pull that idea into the mainstream, leaving the smaller guys to redefine trend again.

  2. Fascinating article, cheers Mark. The beer industry has helped shaped America and inventions such as canning and refrigeration have had a huge impact on non-drinkers and beer lovers alike.

  3. I wondered if you were chanelling Maureen Ogle there, Dredgie ;-) Nice piece. One thing, they tell me Mendocino (no 'h') is pronounced men-doh-seeno. I always pronounced it the way you spelt it...

  4. Have you been reading Ben McFarland?

  5. Leigh - Cheers! Fancied stretching the writing muscle a bit with this one!

    Adam - It's amazing what beer pioneered in terms of technology and commercial advancement in the late 19th century - I find it fascinating.

    Sid - Extra 'h' removed. If that's the only letter in the wrong place over 2,000 words then I'll be quite happy!

  6. "Americans were drinking spirits in the dark while the Germans were drinking lager in bright beer halls. "

    Nothing I have read has suggested this convincingly. Americans were drinking beer, cider, etc. There was plenty of pre-lager brewing: Americans on the frontier farms were drinking apple jack (boozy iced apple syrup) as one of Michael Pollen's books describes. Check Google News archives for the actual reaction to German lager - violence and clash, corporate manipulation and graft.

  7. "In the 1870s, brewers looked back to Germany and saw the bright beers of Bohemia – pale gold, light-bodied, clear and sparkling."

    In the 1870's almost no pale Lager was brewed in Germany. Dark Munich-style Lager was King.

  8. Here Dredgie, how's your weirdometer? I was in Cask for my weekly drunkening this afternoon, and who do you suppose came in?

    A couple from CA, the male of the party being a guy called Mark, who brews at Mendocino! I shit you not. They're in the UK for a week or so visiting Mark's now-resident-here sister. They drank Dark Star, and will be heading to MCR in a day or so.

  9. Alan - I wouldn't have put that if I hadn't have read it. And that sentence is more there because I like the 'spirits in the dark' thing. But still, by the accounts, taverns weren't the nicest of places to sit for a drink.

    Ron - I've updated the word 'Germany' to 'Europe'. I wasn't far off.

    Sid - No way! What a weird and wonderful coincidence. Cheers to that!

  10. There was almost no pale Lager brewed anywhere but Bohemia in 1870.

  11. Mark, in US communities pre-1850 it would have been as much the case of making it themselves at home, taking the beer home or having it anywhere, not just in dedicated in taverns. Here's a handy direct reference:

  12. Excellent post Mark, I really enjoyed reading about the evolution of the brewing industry in the US.

  13. Nice bit of cut and pasting.

  14. Hey Mark. The mention of Schlitz at the top grabbed my attention, as a bottle of German IPA (yes, another one!) in my hand right now says it was founded by a August Krug, who was of the same family that ran the "Zum weißen Löwen" tavern that became the Faust brewery, Miltenberg (not far from where I live). The IPA was recently brewed here by Faust to celebrate the father and son who left and founded the brewery that later became Schlitz (Joseph Schlitz bought it from the Krugs 10 years later or so, and the Uihleins came much later, and were related to the Krugs... man... :D). SO, lots more German names to add to that list ;)

  15. Nice summary.

    I remember when I first saw a bottle of Sam Adams beer. My father ordered it in a restaurant in Massachusetts in about 1985. As a teenager, I was becoming fascinated with beer and brewing. The consolidation of the brewing industry at that time was so severe that the idea of a beer that wasn't a Bud, Michelob or Miller seemed alien to me. By the time I was in college a few years later, the brewing scene had simply exploded in New England. By the early ninties, bottle shops even in small towns started to become cornucopias of beer.

    Twenty years later, the variety of beer available in a quality liquor store most anywhere in the US is bewildering. Endless aisles of xperimental, esoteric and even mature (session beers available, decreased emphasis on "stunt" beers) brews are on offer. The biggest change in the last 15 years is that it's mainstream now. Even blue collar bars will have many craft brews on tap. At a typical suburban backyard BBQ, someone will bring bombers of locally-made lambic or weiss. You can find craft brew at gas stations. I think this follows a wider trend of hugely increased appreciation of "artisinal" foods around the US. Unpasteurized cheese, real yogurt, organic produce, grass-fed beef: none of that even existed in the US twenty years ago, now you can find it in mainstream supermarkets. These are all excellent trends.